Wednesday, July 20, 2011

ESSENCE OF KNRAMACHANDRAN POLITICS

Essence of KNRamachandran Politics                                                                           Aravind Sinha.
The most important aspect of Ramachandran’s politics is his understanding of imperialism and the world order that emerged after Second World War. Let us look at what he says in this respect in his documents.
“The consequences of the momentous developments that took place during the post World War II years started disappearing from the debates. There were very little efforts to analyze and ‘develop’ Lenin’s teachings on imperialism according to concrete conditions. The basic changes taking place in the course of changing from colonial to neo-colonial phase were side lined.”
So Ramachandran took upon himself to ‘develop’ Lenin’s teachings in the present ‘phase of neo-colonialism’ after World War II. In this endeavor he found that the fifth characteristic of imperialism, as defined by Lenin, has become obsolete. In Ramachandran’s words:-“With the disappearance of the territorial division of the world as one of the basic features of imperialism, though six decades have elapsed after World War II even though numerous local wars and imperialist aggressive wars continue to take place, no world war have taken place for division and re-division of the world so far.”
Again, regarding these local wars he further says, “But what is taking place now is low intensity warfare as an imperialist of class struggle, a strategy of class war against the masses of the people.” So, according to Ramachandran these ‘local wars’ and “imperialist aggressive wars” are “class war against the masses of the people,” not war between imperialist powers. In this way Ramachandran has not only declared ‘territorial division of the world among imperialist powers’ obsolete, but has also declared that in the present phase of neo-colonialism, war among imperialist powers has become non-existent. So, in his opinion this characteristic features of imperialism that inter-imperialist rivalry and wars are inevitable in the era of imperialism, has also become obsolete. So what is left after World War II is a world which is divided between imperialist powers on the one hand, and new colonies on the other. Imperialist powers in this world have succeeded in resolving their conflict for territory and markets peacefully, and have imposed a neo-colonial exploitative system on other countries which are neo-colonies of the united imperialism. Imperialism unleashes aggressive wars and the people when they rise against this system of neo-colonial system. But no wars are taken place due to rivalry among imperialist powers. In this analysis imperialism become more powerful after World War II they imposed’neo-colonization’ on the world “which is a more pernicious form of colonization.” Then what about successful liberation struggles in Vietnam and other countries of the world? What about cold war between US imperialism and Soviet Social Imperialism? What about present day war going as in Iraq and Afghanistan. Are these not for world hegemony by US imperialism Vis-a Vis other imperialist powers.
The way Ramachandran has ‘developed’ the Lenin’s thesis on imperialism has brought him close to Kautsky’s line of ultra-imperialism or super imperialism. Kautsky visualized a ‘peaceful’ world order in which imperialism resolved their differences peacefully and ruled the colonial people through brute force. In this way a prolonged phase of brutal exploitation and oppression would continue in the world. Lenin on the other hand saw bitter rivalry and wars among the imperialist countries for colonies, raw materials and markets. These wars, local or world war would weaken the imperialist system and provide opportunity to the proletariat and other revolutionary people to make new democratic and socialist Revolutions. That is why Stalin defined, “Leninism is the Marxism in the era of imperialism and proletarian revolution.” Ramachandran going Kautsky’s ways overestimates the strength of imperialism and underestimates the strength and power of the people. Again by rejecting Lenin’s thesis of contradiction being the principal aspect of inter-imperialist relationship leading to war. He rejects the possibility of emerging opportunities for the oppressed people to make successful revolution. Inter-imperialist rivalry and hegemonic designs of the US imperialism have resulted in numerous wars and conflict zones in the world. This weakens imperialist global order and provides opportunities to the revolutionaries to advance revolutionary struggle for NDR and socialism. Present day global financial crisis and melt down is the outcome of all the contradictions of imperialist system which Lenin had characterized.  In this way Ramachandran has fallen in the ditch of right opportunism by rejecting Lenin.
Basing upon this wrong analysis Ramachandran makes serious mistakes regarding Indian Revolution. He Says, “The principal contradiction in present day India and the path of revolution leading to victory of the NDR can be defined and developed only based on the Marxist-Leninist analysis of Indian State as a state under neo-colonialism or a neo-colonial one.”He further elaborates his ideas on these vital questions in the following way:- “In the present neo-colonial conditions I  India the principal contradiction is between the alliance of imperialism, comprador bureaucratic capital and landlords on the one hand and the broad masses of the people on the other.”
On the question of path of Indian revolution, he rejects the concept of ‘area-wise seizure of political power’ and ‘base areas’ as influence of localism and advocates: “significant changes that have taken place in the concrete situation in recent decades, especially after launching of neo-liberal offensive by imperialism and the native ruling classes call for a country wide offensive by the revolutionary forces mobilizing tens of millions.”
From these passages it is clear that Ramachandran does not accept semi-feudalism also which he had accepted in 2005 Unity conference. So, he has replaced ‘feudalism by ‘landlordism’ in his definition of Principal Contradiction in India. So, in his analysis semi-feudalism is not there, and a capitalist system has been foisted on the whole country by Imperialism. So, economic and political developments are one inter connected whole in the country. No fault lines, discontinuities distortions or disfigurements of local natures are caused due to feudalism. So, the revolutionary forces should, and can be organized at all India level, and they should launch all India revolutionary offensives.  Brave words! But hardly any action matching these brave words. Any person even a with even a ordinary knowledge of contemporary political history of India knows that most of the movements have been regional or state wise or local in nature. But Ramachandran lives in world of imagination built by his erroneous concepts. And what are weapons in this all India Revolutionary offensive? It is fighting lections in as many seats as possible, even at those places where his party is nearly non-existent. He thinks that just by giving call to fight against imperialism during elections he can mobilize “millions” at All India level to launch an all India offensive.
This way Ramachandran’s line is a line of opportunism and parliamentary cretinism. By rejecting Lenin’s thesis on imperialism in the name of ‘developing’ Lenin’s teaching he has embraced the concept of Second International led by Karl Kautsky. This is the line of social democracy, capitulations to imperialism, and parliamentary path. So, this line must be rejected lock, stack and barrel.
===================================================================


Saturday, July 2, 2011

ON THE CHARACTER OF INDIAN STATE


Having arrived at the conclusion that there is need to “develop” Lenin’s teachings on the question of imperialism in accordance with concrete conditions; or in an attempt to fill the vacuum said to have emerged due to the alleged failure on the part of Marxist Leninist forces or rectify the distortions that crept into the theoretical and political analysis of the developments, especially in the post second world war period, KNRamachandran has come out with certain formulations. These formulations, in essence, declare that certain essential aspects of Lenin’s teachings on imperialism had come obsolete and propose certain amendments to Marxism Leninism.
Ramachandran asserts that in the “neo colonial phase” of imperialism, “basic changes “or “qualitatively distinct changes” had taken place in the form of imperialist exploitation and hegemony. More importantly, he concludes: (a)”the fifth characteristic, “the territorial division of the whole world among the biggest capitalist powers is completed” is no longer evident. (b)”with the disappearance of the territorial division of the world as one of the basic features of imperialism, though six decades have elapsed after world war 2nd  no world war has taken place for division and re division of the world.”(3) In the neo colonial phase, “financial oligarchy, along with this the speculative character of finance capital has achieved predominance” (4)”The whole imperialist economy and political frame-work under went significant changes.”(5)”As possibilities for territorial extension of the market, bringing in new areas under its control no longer exists; it can be achieved only through expansion of market and financial sectors, an intensification of exploitation of human and natural resources of the neo colonial countries”.
These conclusions are theoretically anti Marxist-Leninist; politically are wrought with danger of driving one into the reformist mire; factually are based on a total distortion of facts and politically carry harmful consequences for the revolutionary movement and the struggle against imperialism.
These conclusions seek to reform imperialism. They assure that the imperialists are no more in a position to extend the areas of control and they are left with only economic means but not the means of war to extend their markets, financial sectors and loot of human and natural resources. In essence, according to these conclusions the inter-imperialist contradictions and rivalries in the present world cannot go beyond the competition in the economic sphere and war as a means of major imperialist powers to settle the question who dominate the world has become obsolete.
But the realities are otherwise.
Today, the imperialist powers, more particularly US imperialists, are doing everything to retain their monopoly on most sophisticated and most destructive weapons – both in terms of quantity and quality. The US imperialists and, in a lesser degree, other imperialist powers are having military bases at a number of chosen strategic points throughout the world. They had built up military alliances such as NATO and are using the same threaten, attack and subjugate other countries. The US attempts and moves to encircle of arms and Russia militarily, maintain its upper hand over it in the strength of arms and Russia attempts to oppose it and resort to counter moves are unending features in the present world. We find no country today which is not threatened or interfered or bullied or attacked by the US imperialists. We had seen many proxy wars in different countries waged by the imperialist powers, more particularly the two super powers, in their contention for hegemony. It is a fact that the imperialist powers who were engaged in armed invasions and who are responsible for many mini and proxy wars and internal armed conflicts and coups, etc. had shed blood, brought human and material destruction and committed barbarities many times greater than what we had seen in two world wars taken together. In every region in the world, the US maintains military out posts such as Israel and it is engaged in constantly multiplying them with a view to use them to bring the countries and people under its control and domination.
So none of the basic features of imperialism, including the territorial division of markets, has either disappeared or was abandoned by the imperialist powers. The contradictions, rivalries and contention for markets and spheres of influence continued all along last six decades period. Some times their intensity was either more or less; sometimes they had manifested between the two main or leading rivals. Sometimes, the imperialists had settled their disputes over share of spoils ‘peacefully’ as they were then confronted with more formidable enemy in the form of oppressed people or a potential rival within their own camp. Direct and physical control on a country or region is not the only form or method that determines whether a particular country or region has come under the influence or domination of an imperialist power. There are different forms and degrees of influence or domination. It is not just subjective wishes of imperialist powers that determine the form. They act in accordance with the concrete situation and decide what can be a best course and form to realize their aims in the given situation. War has never been the only weapon, but one important weapon to decide the question, who dominates a country or region. The imperialists use this weapon basing on their assessment of the concrete situation.
Ramachandran’s  conclusion that the possibilities for territorial division of markets and their expansion “no longer exist today “have no relation to the realities. His argument, basing on the fact that since no world war has taken place after 1945 we can conclude that the imperialists had abandoned war as a means of dividing or expanding their markets or areas of domination is too simplistic.
The developments in the last more than six decades were full of zig zags, ups and downs and turbulence. The balance of powers within the imperialist camp as well as between imperialism in general and US in particular on one side and the democratic, national socialist forces had been undergoing many changes and ups and downs. While forces of revolution are struggling hard against many odds to withstand and turn the situation in their own favor, the imperialists and reactionary forces that are plagued by their own crises, contradictions and rivalries are doing everything to pursue their own interests. The US imperialists who had come up in the post-second-world war period the leader of world capitalist system, had been doing everything to cut to size other imperialist powers while, at the same time, finding common cause with them in the suppression of forces of revolution. They are working with a clear aim of weakening and preventing other imperialist powers from becoming potential contenders not only economically, but also militarily for world hegemony. These courses of development show that the inter-imperialist contradictions and rivalry continue to operate even today in every sphere, including military. While antagonism and irreconcilability are the fundamental features of inter-imperialist contradictions, the contentions or collusions among the imperialists would change their positions from primary to secondary and, sometimes, both go together in accordance with the concrete conditions. Declaring that war no longer remains a means of resolving the inter-imperialist contradictions is nothing but denying the fundamental character of imperialism and attempting at reforming Leninism.
Ramachandran says: “except for some military bases and enclaves, imperialist countries are no more keeping any countries, even the smallest ones, under their territorial control. Even after aggression and occupation of Afghanistan and Iraq by US led imperialist forces, puppet governments were soon constituted and even fake elections were organized to give them pseudo democratic cover. “
It is height of absurdity.
In his eagerness to present imperialism as a ‘peaceful’ vegetarian animal, Ramachandran is minimizing the imperialist strategic, world wide spread of military network into just “some military bases and enclaves.” In his eagerness to prove that the imperialist are no more in a position to pursue the policy of dividing or re-dividing the territories, he is excluding even countries ruled by the puppets (and protected by the occupationist armed forces) from the countries territorially occupied by the imperialists. What is the difficulty for him to call the countries like Afghanistan and Iraq as neo colonies? His difficulty is: this will go against his own conclusion that ‘the imperialist countries are no longer keeping any countries, even the smallest ones under their territorial occupation’. It goes against his conclusion that the world today is ‘divided into the imperialist countries and large number of neo-colonial countries’ if he puts countries like Afghanistan and Iraq in a category different from others. His apprehension is: if he puts the countries like this in a separate category, the category of neo-colony, he may be compelled to put countries like India, not ruled by the puppets but by the comprador bourgeois-landlord classes who are in alliance with imperialism, in the category of semi-colony. So, he has chosen to put all these countries in one basket – basket of neo-colonial countries, as countries outside the realm of territorial domination or control of imperialist powers.
Ramachandran has come out with one more dangerous formulation. He says, “instead of territorial domination these countries under the former colonial domination are now controlled through their ever intensifying integration to imperialist capital-market system and internationalization of production through international financial agencies and MNCs.”
Lenin explained: “Monopolist capitalist associations, cartels, syndicates and trusts first divided the home market among them and obtained more or less complete possession of the industry of their own country. But under capitalism the home market is inevitably bound up with the foreign market. Capitalism long ago created a world market. As the export of capital increased, and as the foreign and colonial connections and ‘spheres of influence’ of the monopolist associations expanded in all ways, things ‘naturally’ gravitated towards an international agreement among these associations, and towards the formation of international cartels. This is a new stage of world concentration of capital and production, incomparably higher than the preceding stages.” Lenin called it ‘super monopoly’ too.
So, capitalism - in its investment of capital, production and marketing is international in character. Imperialism which has assumed the leadership of world capitalism has taken it to new heights. Thus it is not at all a new phenomenon.
Today, there is a trend in the international communist movement which advocates that the international class struggle and world revolution had assumed more importance than earlier because the internationalization of production and market and consequent and inevitable fall of national boundaries are a growing phenomenon. Objectively, this theory only serves the purpose of relegating the task of revolution to a secondary place in the individual countries and reducing the international struggle against imperialism into an abstract and general campaign.
Lenin, in his time, too confronted this problem in a different form. Here is what Lenin wrote: “certain bourgeois writers (now joined by Karl kautsky, who has completely abandoned the Marxist Position he had held, for example, in 1909) have expressed the opinion that international cartels, being one of the most striking expressions of the internationalization of capital, give the hope of peace among nations under capitalism. Theoretically, this opinion is absolutely absurd, which in practice it is sophistry and a dishonest defense of the worst opportunism.”
Lenin has dealt the slogan of “United states of the world “too. He wrote, “A united states of world (not of Europe alone) is the state form of the unification and freedom of nations which we associate with socialism – until the time when the complete victory of communism brings about the total disappearance of the state, including the democratic. As a separate slogan, however, the slogan of a united states of the world would hardly be a correct one, first,   because it merges with socialism; second, it may be wrongly interpreted to mean that the victory of socialism in a single country is impossible, and it may also create misconceptions as to the relations of such country to the others.
On the question of colonialism and neo colonialism; Ramachandran has come out with some confused and inconsistent ideas.
He confused the form with content. He calls a country which, even according to him is in process of neo colonization as a neo colony. He views, neo colonization not as a policy pursued by imperialism to exploit and control another country but as a “phase” of imperialism. He sees no difference between a country ruled by the Comprador-bureaucratic bourgeois and land lord classes in alliance with imperialism and a country ruled by puppets installed and protected by the imperialists.
When Lenin concluded in 1916 that “the territorial division of the whole world among the biggest capitalist powers is completed,” he did not mean that the entire world was divided in to ‘imperialist countries and a large number of colonial countries’ as Ramachandran puts it now (imperialist countries and large number of colonial countries).
Lenin said,” Not only are the two main groups of countries, those owning colonies, and the colonies themselves, but also diverse forms of dependent countries which politically, and formally independent, but in fact, are enmeshed in the net of financial and diplomatic dependence, typical of this epoch.”
Ramachandran referred to ‘semi colony’ as ‘a transitional form,’ a’ form of dependence’. He mentioned Portugal an independent sovereign state as a “British protectorate” but, at the same, a country owning small colonies.
The point here is: It is simplistic and wrong to put all countries be it in the period of colonial period or neo colonial period in one broad vision. Because, in both these periods, countries were or are under diverse forms of dependence or control.
As everyone knows, the neo colonialism as a policy of imperialism is a post second world war phenomenon. The policy of colonialism received a powerful blow with the defeat of Fascism, victories or advance of the national liberation, national independence movements and people’s revolutions in the world. Historically, colonialism became obsolete and stood thoroughly exposed. However, the imperialism was only weakened but not over thrown. In the face of rising tide of national liberation, national independence movements and people’s revolutions the imperialist powers had to change their tactics to survive and pursue their policy of plunder and domination. The US imperialists, who had certain advantages over the other imperialist powers, had come to the fore as a champion of these new tactics and policy, came to be known as neo colonial country, the imperialists in general and US in particular had put this policy in practice in accordance with the concrete conditions in each country and region. They adopted the processes and different forms of control and domination.
The essence of debate and struggle between the CPSU on one side and the CPC on the other side at the time of Great debate on the question of imperialism and neo colonialism was: the CPSU asserted that the colonialism has collapsed once forever and therefore, the proletariat was left with no task of leading the national and democratic revolutions and peoples’ revolutions. The CPC said that imperialism has not certainly given up the colonialism, but merely change to new form, neo colonialism. It has correctly pointed out that this neo colonialism is more pernicious and more sinister form of colonialism and therefore, the national, democratic and people’s revolutions must be carried with all firmness and thorough to the end.
At the same time, the CPC has evaluated the concrete situation in the countries of Asia, Africa and Latin America. It said: “The whole groups of countries have declared their independence. Many of this countries have not completely shaken off imperialist and colonial control and enslavement and remains object of imperialist plunder and aggression as well as areas of contention between the old and neo colonialists. In some, the old colonialists have changed into neo colonialists and retain their colonial rule through their trained agents. In others, the wolf left through the front door but the tiger has entered through back door, the old colonialism being replaced by the new, and more powerful and more dangerous, US imperialism. The people of Asia and Africa are seriously menaced by the tentacles of neo colonialism, represented by US imperialism.”
The CPC also warned that the imperialists, headed by the US enslave or control countries which have already declared their independence by organizing military blocks, setting military bases, establishing ‘federations’ or ‘communities’ and fostering puppet regimes. By means of economic ‘aid’ or other forms, they retain these countries as markets…….. Source of raw material and outlets for their export of capital, plunder the riches and suck the blood of people of these countries. They use UN to interfere in the internal affairs of a country, subject them to military, economic and cultural aggression. When these ‘peaceful’ means fail, they engineer military coups, carry out subversion or even resort to direct armed intervention and aggression. The developments in the last more than three decades had confirmed the correctness of this entire evaluation.
By his refusal to clearly define the basic features of neo colony and to demarcate it from other countries Ramachandran is only diluting the meaning of a neo colony.
Ramachandran has come to the fore with criticism or comments on the Marxist Leninist force that they had not made enough efforts to study and analyze post second world war period. In their international struggle against imperialism, they had put the main edge against the US, as they assessed the US imperialism as the biggest exploiter, biggest oppressor and the common enemy of entire world people. When the Soviet Union has come up as a social imperialist super power with designs and moves and entered into contention with another super power – US – for world hegemony and both seemed to be pushing the world towards another global war, the Marxist Leninist forces had rightly focused their main edge of international struggle against the two super powers as the biggest exploiters, biggest oppressors and main source of war in the given international situation at the time. They pursued an international line of opposing imperialism in general, the hegemonies and war policies of two powers in particular and advancing revolutions in their own countries in accordance with basic tasks and concrete situation in their countries. When the Soviet Union collapsed and the US as a single super power has stepped up its hegemonic drive in an offensive way, the Marxist Leninist forces took note of this change and pursued the line and tasks suitably. In the entire period the Marxists Leninists firmly upheld Lenin’s definition on imperialism, the formulation, the era of imperialism and proletarian revolution and pursued line and task by applying Marxism Leninism Mao Tse Tung thought to concrete conditions.
Mistakes in the evaluation of situations; in the application of theory to concrete situations and the sectarian or right deviationist tilts in formulating the task and practice had occurred in some occasions and on the part of some sections of Marxist Leninist forces. Such mistakes and deviations, no doubt, proved costly. However, they were within the reach of correction provided the concerned forces took the guidance and help of Marxism- Leninism- Mao’s thought. Ramachandran’s criticism or comment on the CPC and the Marxist Leninist forces is only a product of his conclusion that some aspects of Lenin’s teaching on imperialism had become obsolete and need amendment. So, naturally, he negates the efforts made by the Marxist Leninist forces in right direction.
On the characterization of Indian Society and state Ramachandran says: “India is a neo colonial country”.
“With this the neo colonization unprecedentedly intensified the Indian economy increasingly integrated to international monopoly capital and market system, with speculative capital dominating all spheres. India, like other former colonial, semi colonial and dependent countries of the colonial phase has become a neo colonial country, a country under ever intensifying neo colonization.”
“Thus this country was transformed from a colony of British imperialism to a country under neo colonial domination by various imperialist powers, especially US imperialism. Later when socialist Soviet Union degenerated to a social imperialist super power and the imperialist contradiction between US and Soviet Union started intensifying, this contradiction was reflected in the Indian ruling classes also. But in the main this inter-imperialist contradictions was utilized by the Indian state for maneuvering for its benefits and to pursue a hegemonic policy in south Asia.”
Here Ramachandran in infirm and inconsistent in his ideas on the question. He contradicts his neo colony characterization when he also says that India is a “country ever intensifying neo colonization” which only means that the process is still on.
Ramachandran agrees that various imperialist powers are contending in India for domination with US being in an upper hand in this contention. He agrees that the inter-imperialist contradictions are reflecting in the Indian ruling classes and the Indian state has utilized the same for maneuvering for its benefits. Elsewhere in his path document he explained that “even while the India big bourgeoisie and bureaucratic class have contradiction with imperialism which is often reflected in their maneuvers to utilize the inter-imperialist contradictions for their benefit, their collaboration with imperialism is basic…..”   “So whether one calls it a junior partner or dependent bourgeoisie, its basic character remains the same.”
Our outline Programme says:  “The ruling classes represented by the comprador-bureaucratic bourgeoisie and big land lord classes depending and serving imperialism is engaged in joint exploitation and plunder of the country and people.”At another place it also said, “In the present world situation, the neo colonial form of exploitation is intensifying with every passing year and various imperialist powers are contending for dominant position in India.”
Puppets cannot be expected to be in a position to either ‘share power’ or ‘collaborate’ or ‘junior partner or engage themselves in ‘joint exploitation and plunder’ together with imperialist power or ‘utilize the inter-imperialist contradiction’ and pursue a policy of ‘hegemonism’ in a region. A puppet as long as he is a puppet cannot pursue economic and political interests’ independent form and opposed to his imperialist master. But a comprador as long as he is a comprador can enjoy some maneuverability with in frame of serving imperialism on the whole vis a vis a particular imperialist power when they are contending for domination in the country. 
When we call India as semi colonial we are clear that it is neither a colony nor an independent country. It is a country which was transformed from a colony to semi colony. It is transitional form adopted by the imperialists in collusion with the Indian ruling classes to safeguard their own interests in the face of irresistibly surging movement for national liberation in India; collapse of Fascism, national forces in to a formidable force. So this semi colonial form was a road block laid on the way to prevent India from becoming an independent country. Their move to transfer power to the Indian ruling classes and withdraw to the background was also a sort of step backward, again, to protect their interests in the changed conditions. A semi colony may either be pushed back into colonial embrace if the imperialists succeed in their counter revolutionary designs and neo colonial drive may save itself from this disaster and take a road of independence and democracy if the revolutionary forces succeed in leading the NDR to victory.
Neo colony is a country ruled by puppets of one imperialist power or a bloc of powers. It need not necessarily be a military occupied country. State here may sometimes do the garb of democracy, independence and sovereignty to befool the people. But it is the imperialist masters who decide its policies and the state will be required to execute them to the best satisfaction of the imperialist master.
In semi colony, such as India, the stage of revolution will be NDR and overthrowing feudalism and imperialism are its basic tasks. In the present phase, while according to primary importance to agrarian revolution as it brings the main revolutionary force – toiling peasants and the rural masses – into revolutionary action we would do everything to intensify the struggle against imperialism. The revolution may go over to the phase of national war even within the frame of NDR when the situation matures for it. In a neo colony, the stage of revolution will be National Democratic Revolution. Here the principal thrust of revolution will be directed against imperialism and their puppets, while at the same time, doing everything to strengthen the democratic content of the revolution by intensifying the struggle to weaken and dismantle the feudal social basis of imperialism in the country. When the country becomes an occupied one, the revolution assumes the character of National Liberation Movement from the beginning and all other struggles, including the struggle for democratic reform would be linked in a way to strengthen and advance NLM as a whole.
Ramachandran concluded that ‘recognizing neo colonization as the present phase of imperialism and finance capital, and characterizing the Indian State as neo colonial is Marxist Leninist Position. The revolutionary orientation to lead the NDR forward can be developed only based on these positions.” He argues that characterizing India as semi colonial after so many momentous developments in the post world war 2nd years has “already led to the communist movement vacillating between right opportunism and left sectarianism and vice versa to the failure to concretely analyze the Indian situation and develop the theory and practice of Indian revolution.”
These are empty assertions. In his entire note, Ramachandran has brought nothing to show how he differentiates a neo colony from a semi colony except repeating certain oblivious and uncontroversial facts such as that the imperialist countries, especially US imperialists are pursuing neo colonial forms of exploitation and plunder to gain domination over India and the policies associated with the globalization brought an added momentum and speed for the neo colonial drive. He agrees with all the formulations and elaborations contained in the outline of the programme which are quite in consonance with the semi colonial character of the Indian society and state. Despite all this, he concludes that the non adoption of the word, ‘neo colony’ has already led the communist movement to vacillate between right opportunism and sectarianism, etc. it is unfair.
Barring a section of CRs who over a period of time, have arrived at the conclusion that India is relatively independent, all the other CRs continue to adopt the semi colonial formulation with same elaboration as we have made in our outline Programme. There was a time when the words semi colony and neo colony synonymously used, but the word neo colony was abandoned eventually after a discussion and debate which led to see a clear differentiation between the two in content and form. It was correct. So it is simplistic as well as sweeping to attribute right opportunism or left sectarianism to the semi colonial formulation. To claim that neo colonial formulation alone is a Marxist Leninist position without explaining where it qualitatively differs from semi colony and what changes it brings in the tasks and direction of revolution defined in our outline Programme.
So we must adopt the characterization of ‘semi colonial and semi feudal society and state’ for India with all the elaboration contained in our outline Programme.
*******************************************************************






Monday, June 6, 2011

Comrade Kanu Sanyal’s SELF CRITICISM.

Before dealing with the issue of self criticism of mine i.e. Kanu snayal it is very important to touch upon some crucial developments of the period between 1962 to 1967. The political, organizational and related agrarian struggles of the period were so complex that it becomes very difficult to have a comprehensive view of it by the outsiders. The CPI party was split and virtually was working separately. Com. Charu Majumdar, Souren Bose and Kanu Sanyal with many other comrades were under detention in 1962. Com.CM was released from the jail in 1963 for contesting election and afterwards com. SB and KS were released last in 1964. Com.Khokon Mazumder was not arrested in 1962 perhaps due to his connection with the rightist elements of CPI. In the last part of 1964 KS was again arrested and released in 1966 June. Com.Khokon was arrested in 1965 September and released in 1966 June. But KS and Jangal santal were again arrested in the last part of 1966 and Jangal was released just before the Assembly election. KS was released only a few days before the election. The agrarian struggle was continuing and under the situation the comrades went underground. Comrades may remember that a shadow committee was formed within the CPI (M) but the committee did not function properly and as the struggle got momentum the role of the shadow committee withered away. Only the path of individual consultations was going on as and when necessary.

As com.CM was ill, he remained open throughout the period of 1967-68 excepting a week of detention in 1968. In this complex situation Com. CM became the only spokesman on behalf of the comrades who were spearheading the movement and were in U.G. I am not using the word usurping but due to the extraordinary situation Com.CM got the opportunity to have a free play and started sending directions to UG comrades whom on many occasions created several problems and sometimes his instruction went against the concrete situation. This is the time when com.cm took advantage of his position which elevated him to the position of “knows everything” and others were slighted. The police onslaught was day by day becoming bad to worse. We had guns but no ammunitions. KS time and again pressurized for arrangements of ammunition to encounter the police but ammunitions were never procured. Com.CM was telling to kill the landlords who had already vacated the villages. The entire Siliguri Taluk was divided into four police regions and police were carrying on their policy of encircling us. With the guns becoming totally unworkable due to dearth of ammunition the military situation went against the UG comrades and politically a vacuum was created due to absence of centralized political leadership in the struggle area. The situation was totally unfavorable for the comrades and even maintaining hideouts became impossible and out of question. The entire organization was paralyzed and even reading, writing or documentation was out of question. And this caused absence of documentation. Whether this reality should be taken seriously into their estimation or not that is for comrades to decide. But the fact remains that the reality could not be denied or over-ruled.



The article “More on Naxalbari” was written in Vishakhapatnam jail in 1972 before the demise of Com.cm and he was under arrest and naturally CM did not know it. Obviously, many questions would arise in the minds of comrades. In spite of knowing many issues why KS did not oppose com.cm from the beginning that is from the period of formation of CPI (ML) in 1969 and rather remained mute. This is wholly legitimate doubt for the comrades. Marxism-Leninism is a science, and it must be followed honestly from the beginning to the end while analyzing political developments of a period of time.

To put the history in a straight and honest way, we must have a Marxist understanding of the whole episode of Naxalbari struggle. AICCCR and formation of CPI (ML) visa vise the role of com.cm. Every comrade knows about the LIN PIAO affair in CPC and when it happened. To understand the situation it will not be unfair and out of context if there is mentioning of Com.Chou En LAI’s explanation regarding Lin Pio’s affair in the history of CPC during its 10th congress.



Com.Chou En Lai explained that Lin Piao had a process of development and unfolding himself and the CPC had also a process of development of understanding and know him. This is purely dialectical process of dealing with the matter. Likewise com.cm had a process of development and unfolding himself in the history of CPI (ML) and KS had also process of development in knowing com.cm.

Mao Tse Tung thought teach us that in human society activity in production develops step by step from a lower level to a higher level and consequently Man’s knowledge, whether of nature or of society, also develop step by step from a lower to a higher level, that is from the shallow one to the deeper one from one sided to many sided.” This phenomenon in regard to com.cm can be understood if we try to grasp it. In spite of knowing tit-bits regarding cm, why KS kept mum and went on supporting by keeping silent can be construed us absolutely personality issue. Com.CM was a class mate of KS’s elder brother. More over Com.CM joined communist movement long before KS and also one of the leaders of the Glorious Tebhaga movement in 1946. Many a story regarding Tebhaga movement, his role in the movement was wide spread. This led to create some sort of legend and unconditional acceptance of com.cm which created a sort of personality cult. KS personally know that cm gave up his land title as a land lord in favor of peasants during the movement against Benami Land in 1959. More over CM had great quality to pose the problems of class struggle in a concrete way. So, KS confidence on CM was not unfounded. At the same breath having the landlord class origin CM had some sort of impatience and impulsiveness in dealing with political matters. KS was working with him under his guidance since 1952 and there developed a feeling of leader and led. This created hindrance on many occasion. In spite of this KS opposed CM on many occasions during CPI days. He also criticized him on many occasions.Com.cm during that period had another quality to accept his guilt and make self criticism. Com.cm raised the issue of agrarian revolution and armed struggle in Darjeeling district. But during the later part of 1967 he developed some sort of haughtiness and slowly developed commanding attitude in political and organizational matters. The presence of some younger comrades around him helped develop this situation. They began to praise him like anything. KS opposed com.cm vehemently against his line of annihilation till 1967, but these younger comrades who had less education of Marxism and mass struggle supported him very strongly. And for this, com.cm developed in him, a sense of infallibility. And once he was out of Siliguri this sense of infallibility increased further because of the presence of a new type of political coterie in AICCCR and later on in CPI (ML). Com.cm raised the slogan of annihilation line and posed the matter in his own way. Here we should remember that laws of motion in human activity especially in the matter of class struggle cannot be halted at will if not struggled vehemently. The ground around com.cm was fertile with the help of new comrades, the coterie and party bourgeoisies class. Although KS tried to oppose cm during Naxalbari struggle, he, however could not maintain his position afterwards.

The line of annihilation of class enemies secretly and conspiratorially was enunciated by com.cm and so he is mainly and wholely responsible and for this he cannot be absolved. His line was defeated during Naxalbari struggle but KS also failed to carry on the struggle against this line in a sustained way. KS suffered from anti Marxist ideas of leader and led. KS opposed com.cm on many political junctures but in the wider panorama KS took a most non Marxist and anti Marxist stand during the formation of CPI (ML) visa-vise the role of com.cm. Although CM’s line failed and was defeated in Naxalbari struggle in 1967; but when KS found most of the comrades of other states were supporting com.cm and the line of annihilation was already in application in wider panorama KS took the position of “let me wait and see” at this stage. This showed that KS actually shunned Marxism and yielded to empiricism and practiced worst form of liberalism. KS silence in 1969 during the formation of the party as well as his silence during the party congress in 1970 was taken as mute support for cm’s line. So KS is equally responsible for the anti Marxist line practiced by the CPI (ML). So, KS cannot absolve himself from the wrong line. KS comes of a petty bourgeois class under the influence of feudal practice and his introvert nature of being no -assertive in political matters in that period helped com.cm in propagating his anarchist and terrorist line. Why these things happened? KS think that his non Marxist approach was due to various factors – frequent going to jail and coming out from 1959 to 1969, long UG life, 100 days hunger strike in jail and above all confusion about long standing comrades and frequent changes and separation in comradely camps. All these things together led to the development of some sort of proneness to liberalist approach. Another problem was that KS as District cadre has less confidence on himself and felt that he would not be able to gather much support behind him and for his introvert nature (psychic) he allowed himself to think ‘let it go’. This is pure and simple bourgeois approach relying on empiricism. KS owns up his responsibility but it must not forget that Com.CM WAS THE PROPOUNDER OF THIS LINE SINCE 1965 AND HE COULD NOT AVOID PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANARCHIST AND TERRORIST LINE. It should be remembered that terrorism is also armed struggle basing on Bourgeois Philosophy that heroes are the makers of history. Marxist philosophy teach us - People and People alone are the makers of history. After the vast and painful experience KS stands by Marxism.






===================================================================
                                     

Kanu Sanyal with CEC members of CPI(ML) in Ruppur

Kanu Sanyal with his comrade in arms, comrade Asit Sinha


Kanu Sanyal with comrade Pradeep Debnath who use to look after Kanu Sanyal till his death
Comrade Kanu Sanyal with Subodh Mitra

Party commune and residence of  Kanu Sanyal

Kanu Sanyal while getting his shaving done

Kanu Sanyal while having his food at his residence

Kanu Sanyal while having his food at his residence


Kanu Sanyal in Kerala 1981

Kanu Sanyal with kerala shabdam weekly reporter Gopalakrishnan



 

Visitors

flagcounter.com/more/OFw2">free counters